I happen upon these photos this past summer cleaning out a basement closet. This is a craft I have repeated a number of times. But this was my first attempt - my best guess is 2001! In this photo the pine cone carollers are painted various colours. But in other versions I chose to have the kids paint them white and add a bit of silver glitter. They also used brown pipe cleaners for the arms to make them look like snowmen. They always turned out great.